School Choice and Religious Freedom | Education News

by Greg Forster -

An ?interfaith??group has send a hyperventilating letter to Bobby Jindal calling Louisiana?s new school voucher program ?a blatant attack on the religious freedom clauses in the United States Constitution.? And that?s one of the less painfully overwrought passages.?There?s no hope of getting sound legal, moral, theological?or sociological reasoning from such people, but I thought I?d take the occasion to revisit some of the reasons why school choice is a vital step forward, not backward, for religious freedom.

1) Fair play, the rule of law and equal treatment. Religious freedom requires that religious people and institutions be treated the same way everyone else is treated. I would think this would be so obvious as to be axiomatic. Yet everywhere you turn around, people think that if religious schools participate in the American education system on the same terms as other schools ? which is really all school choice does -?that is somehow a threat to religious freedom. What if we applied this reasoning to other sectors? If the church is burning down, don?t call the fire department! If someone sprays swastikas on the synagogue, don?t call the police! Don?t hook up the mosque to the municipal water lines! That would be a taxpayer subsidy for religion, you know.

2) Childrearing, formation?and faith communities. As many people know, one of the most important Supreme Court decisions on religious freedom upheld the right of the Amish to raise their children according to Amish tradition against compulsory attendance laws. The details of the reasoning that the court used to reach that conclusion are problematic, but we don?t need to be detained by that here; the result was clearly right. A religion is not just a set of intellectual propositions one?assents?to. It is a total way of life, one that may be expressed differently in different individuals, but also coheres in important ways across individuals, and subsists in relationships and institutions as well as in individuals. In other words, a religion?consists not only of individual belief but of a faith community.?The formation?and rearing of children is a necessary part of that; deny people the ability to?raise their children according to the dictates of their conscience and you stamp out religious freedom. You can like this fact or hate it, but it remains a fact.?As the court noted, society has a legitimate mandate to see to it that children are educated in some way, but this must not become an occasion for stamping out religious minorities whose mode of education is different.?Requiring the Amish to raise their children the same way others do is not just tantamount to outlawing the Amish religion; it actually is outlawing the Amish religion. School choice extends this principle further by making American society a place where every family, not just families who prefer secular schools, has equal access to childrearing according to conscience.

3) The death of character in the common school. Pat Wolf has shown that the empirical evidence consistently finds private schools are better at teaching the civic values on which democracy rests. Charles Glenn, James Davison Hunter and others have shown why. The ?common school? model, coralling families of all faiths into one school and requiring that school not to violate the religious beliefs of any of those families, compels schools to become morally neutered. Even where they try to teach moral character, they fail (Hunter has extensive data on this). The reason is simple: the inculcation of moral character requires more than scolding children to be honest, be diligent, etc. Telling edifying stories also fails. Not in every case, but in general, the reliable formation of moral character requires (Hunter again) attachment to something higher and greater than oneself, and the absorbtion at an early age of an intrinsic motivation to prioritize that higher something over the gratification of one?s own desires.

There?s much more to be said, of course, but I didn?t want to let the moment pass without at least this much of a statement of the case.

School Choice and Religious Freedom ? Jay P. Greene?s Blog.

Related posts:

  1. An Interview with Lori Windham: Becket Fund for Religious Freedom Michael F. Shaughnessy - 1) Lori, first of all what...
  2. On Religious Freedom, Years of Battles Ahead David Skeel: The high court calls for accommodating religion. The...
  3. Religious freedom under threat from courts, professor warns Oxford academic Roger Trigg points to ?clear trend? privileging secular...
  4. Secular Left?s intolerance of religious freedom Timothy P.Carney - American Left pretends it's still fighting the...
  5. What is the Meaning of Religious Freedom? Molly Pitcher - From the conclusion of this war we...
  6. Advocates to Celebrate School Choice with Blockbuster Party in New Orleans; Launch of National School Choice Week Planned for January 21, 2012 The Temptations and Ellis Marsalis will headline National School Choice...
  7. More Israelis Choose Religious Schools ? ? More Israelis are choosing religious education for their...
  8. School Censors Religious Words in Graduation Speech ? ? A high school valedictorian in Vermont was forbidden...
  9. Iraqi Students? Bleak Choice: US Occupation or Religious Fundamentalism. Christina Asquith Special Middle-East Correspondent Baghdad-Students tried to close down...
  10. Court Blocks Voucher Plan that Would Fund Religious Schools in Colorado ACLU and Americans United Challenged Scheme that Used Taxpayer Funds...

About or from a variety of publications on EducationViews.org

?The quality and variety of the selections you will find on EducationViews.org is second-to-none on the internet today. Since 1997 we have been providing this service at no cost to education professionals, the public in general and policy makers. Hope you enjoy the articles and commentary. Please forward us to your friends and associates. EducationViews.org is maybe the most effective way to transforming educators. The daily email offers a direct and easy way for busy teachers to grow philosophically. I was skeptical, but once you open the email and decide to read a story, you are hooked and it becomes a daily ritual to check out what?s happening. Educating teachers as to what is really going on in the schools opens up a new worldview and vision of thinking most have not been exposed to. The end result, better informed teachers who have a more effective understanding of the principles that make academic achievement a reality. Great job. The more email addresses of educators you get on your list, the bigger the impact and the more kids you will positively influence.

Source: http://educationviews.org/school-choice-and-religious-freedom/

fantasy baseball st louis cardinals jared sullinger jaleel white levi johnston paul ryan 2013 srt viper